On June 13, Canadian Women in the Literary Arts (CWILA) launched its official website with a mandate to create a discursive space to address the politics of representation, the critical reception of women’s writing (including genderqueer writers, indigenous writers, and other women and/or genderqueer writers of colour), and the fostering of stronger critical communities.
On June 29, Michael Lista, poetry editor for The Walrus and poetry columnist for The National Post, posted a response in the National Post’s Afterword to the launch of CWILA, entitled “On Poetry: The Good in Bad Reviews.” Lista first acknowledged the importance of CWILA’s analysis, then shifted focus to critique a single essay published on the CWILA website, Jan Zwicky’s “The Ethics of the Negative Review,” originally published by The Malahat Review in Fall 2003. Perhaps to account for his decision to focus attention on Zwicky’s essay rather than on CWILA’s central mandate, Lista wrote that he was “surprised” to find this essay “framing the CWILA discussion” and proceeded to attack its primary claims.
Lista’s response to Zwicky’s essay sparked a heated conversation. Some CWILA members have expressed concern that in its present incarnation this conversation draws energy and attention away from the specific feminist concerns CWILA was formed to address and redress. Other CWILA members regard verbal violence as an issue central to feminist literary politics and so perceive the conversation to be important. Many CWILA members agree that the discussion has this question as its focus: what kind of review culture do we have, and what kind of review culture do we want to have?
What follows is a list of links to some of the contributions to this conversation—as well as suggestions for further reading.
Jan Zwicky, “The Ethics of the Negative Review”
Michael Lista, “On Poetry: The Good in Bad Reviews”
Jan Zwicky, “Good, bad—and just plain ugly”
Michael Lista, “Five thoughts on Jan Zwicky’s response”
La Panique, “Come at me, Bro”
Kevin McNeilly, “Shares”
Lemon Hound, “On Misdirected Energy”
Ross Leckie, “Some Further Thoughts on Negative Reviewing”
Emily M. Keeler, “Text/Book: He Said/She Said”
E Martin Nolan, “CWILA: What was Lost in the Puppy Fight”
Jan Zwicky, “On Critical Culture”
The Awl, Jane Hu, “A Short History Of Book Reviewing’s Long Decline”
The Believer, Heidi Julavits, “Rejoice! Believe! Be Strong and Read Hard!”
The Chronicle Review, Arthur Krystal, “Should Writers Reply to Reviewers?”
The Urge, Stewart Cole, “An Open Address to the Poetry Community in Canada“